Pages

Sunday, June 3, 2012

ATTACK ON THE MEDIA : Newsmen seek protection from ‘state-sponsored terror’

“Under attack, pray for us.” is the cryptic message from a journalist colleague in Bangladesh that was received with dismay and circulated hurriedly among the Bangladeshi journalistic Diaspora across the globe. Another journalist posted a comment saying “we’re facing state-sponsored terror.”
 
As the democracy in Bangladesh encounters one of the most intractable challenges of its life time, journalists face as much random attacks and deaths as do opposition leaders and activists. Dozens of opposition political leaders have headed for imprisonment since the coming to power of the Awami League- led administration in early 2009; many were kidnapped; and, attack on journalists continued unabated.
 
 The BBC claims at least nine journalists of the bdnews24.com were injured by a bunch of knife-wielding miscreants during an attack on Monday night at the publication’s office, two of them critically. The following day, about 200 journalists staged a protest rally in front of the national press club in Dhaka. Demonstrations also took place in other press clubs around the country.

Such demonstrations have occurred almost frequently since February 11 when, in a pre-dawn attack at their residence, assailants brutally murdered journalist couple Meherun Runi, a senior reporter of ATN Bangla Television, and her husband Sagar Sarowar, news editor of Maasranga Television.
 
Although a number of media reports linked that bone-chilling dual murder with the couple’s probing into a corruption scandal involving power sector deals in which favouritism and handing of kickbacks were discovered, the investigation remained stalled and the killers are at large.
 
Likewise, the attack on bdnews24.com’s office has led to an arrest which is directly linked with a ruling party cabal. Jahidul Islam Sourav, one of the three suspects arrested on Tuesday, confessed to police of being a member of the Juba League, the youth organ of the ruling Awami League. He also admitted to attacking the journalists at the bdnews24.com office.
 
Our investigation and the prima facie evidence indicate that the trend in attacking journalists is part of a move to throttle any kind of dissents in the country. 
 
Only two days prior to the attack on badnews24.com, police have attacked the court correspondents of the Bengali dailies Prothom Alo, Kaler Kantha and Bangladesh protidin in front of Dhaka’s court house. Hours before, three photojournalists -Khaled Sarker, Zahidul Karim and Sajed Karim – from the Bengali daily Prothom Alo, were beaten by police in Dhaka’s Agargaon area while covering a student demonstration.
Such intolerance of the government with all forms of dissent manifested in a brazen manner on March 12 when cable operators were compelled to block television channels ready to telecast an opposition rally live, according to a cabal company executive who insisted not to be named.
 
The attack on the media aside, at least 22 opposition political activists have disappeared during the first four months of this year, according to the rights group Ain-O-Salish Kendra. According to another rights watchdog, Odhikar, 30 persons were victims of ‘enforced disappearance’ in 2011, 18 in 2010 and 2 in 2009; a pattern that validates a plethora of media reports that human rights violations and extra-judicial killings became one of the main tools of suppressing dissents by the regime.
 
At the same time, a discernible change of policy also became evident. Enforced disappearance, locally known as goom, appeared to have replaced as a policy prescription for the much criticized cross-fire-killings by law enforcing agencies. Data shows, with the instances of enforced disappearances increasing, cross fire killing ebbed. Cross-fire killing reduced from 127 in 2010 to 84 in 2011.
 
The policy is crafty and it’s efficacy lies in the fact that none of the recent instances of kidnapping and killing of political dissents could be blamed directly on the government due to the culprits being often plain-clothed party operatives working under hand-picked security stalwarts of the regime’s inner coterie.
 
That is part of the story, as, in the media, one only hears or reads the news of high profiled murders. 
 
According to one report (The New Nation, 09 May, 2012), police have recovered 100 mutilated corpses from different parts of Dhaka and 60 other from adjoining areas during the last four months. The report cautioned, “The actual number of unidentified bodies would be much higher as all of them could not be traced after they went missing. Many of the bodies might have been dumped into rivers which were carried away by strong current.” 
 
Who has the mandate and the audacity to conduct such systematic killings within a sovereign nation? Despite denial from the government that it’s law enforcing agencies are not involved in these killings and disappearances, facts tend to contradict such an assertion. 
 
For instance, another recent high profiled incidence involving Taka 7 million discoveries in the car of a minister’s aide has met with no justice, and, the government failed to explain why and how the main witness of the case, the driver of the car, has disappeared despite being in the custody of the mighty Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB) troopers.
 
As well, two of the main witnesses in the sensational murder in early March of a senior Saudi diplomat stationed in Dhaka, Khalaf Al Ali, are missing and feared to have been forcefully abducted by the same state-sponsored cabal.
 
Even an international uproar following the kidnapping of the main opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party’s ( BNP) organizing secretary, Ilias Ali, on April 17, has made little dent in convincing the government that democratic governance entails accountability, pluralism, tolerance and rule of law. 
 
It’s pretty obvious from hindsight that Ali’s kidnapping was orchestrated to arouse the opposition’s anger and use the instability to arrest and charge main opposition leaders as the main culprits. And that’s what has happened exactly. Concocted charges have netted dozens of senior BNP leaders and most of them have been denied bails.
 
The autocratic character of the government manifested further when a number of senior leaders and ministers started hurling invectives at the US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, following her expression of deep concerns and demand for investigation into the ‘disappearance’ of Ilias Ali and a trade union leader, Aminul Islam, during her recent Dhaka visit. 
 
Global impression about the autocratic nature of the current Bangladesh regime has also solidified in recent months as attacks on the media intensified amidst publication of stories of failed governance, subservience to foreign powers and unfettered corruption. As if the messenger is culpable for the bad message, in response, the media has been vilified, ostracized and victimized for stories that are made by rogue apparatuses and their loyalist cronies. 
 
The World Bank was compelled lately to censor a $2.5 billion funding for the construction of a bridge due to procedural anomalies created under the influence of kickbacks. Yet, the sordid chronicle of stream-rolling the media is a voluminous one by now. 
 
In April 2010, private TV Channel 1 was forced to close its broadcast. In June 2010, the Bengali daily Amar Desh faced an order to stop publication for printing reports critical of the government. The acting editor of the paper, Mahmudur Rahman, was later arrested under the Anti-Terrorism Act. 
 
Rahman disclosed during a court hearing that his captors had beaten him and the notorious Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) officers tied his hands with window bars prior to depriving him of food and sleep.
 
Other journalists were not as lucky as was Rahman, who carries the stature of being a former adviser to the BNP government and a high-profiled business magnet of the country. According to a 2011 report by the Odhikar, 15 journalists were killed, 740 injured, 299 assaulted, 911 threatened, 45 arrested and nine abducted from January 2004 to April 2011. 

BY : M. Shahidul Islam

Friday, May 25, 2012

Bangladesh Railway : Bribery, anomalies rule recruitment

Yusuf Ali Mridha, the suspended general manager (East) of Bangladesh Railway, had recruited more than 600 railway employees on back dates in just two months before an amount of Tk 70 lakh was seized from a microbus of the former railway minister's aide Omar Faruq Talukder.

Railway officials said Mridha had expedited the appointment process with direct support from Faruq, the sacked assistant personal secretary of the then railway minister Suranjit Sengupta. 

Many job seekers have alleged that they had paid money to get jobs in the railway's east zone.

The public administration ministry in August 2010 approved the recruitment of 7,275 railway staff within a year. It later extended the deadline by six months to February 11 this year, as the railway managed to recruit only several hundred staff in the one-year time frame, said the officials.

A total of 1,611 railway employees -- 1,128 in the east zone and 483 in the west zone -- were recruited between August 2010 and February this year. Of them, 624 were appointed in the east zone after the expiry of the February 11 deadline, according to a source in the railway's establishment department.

“One-third of the total recruitment was made after the expiry of the February 11 deadline, and before the seizure of Tk 70 lakh on April 9,” said a senior railway official, asking not to be named. 

Recruitment data are usually sent to the railway headquarters every month, but the establishment department did not get any recruitment data of the railway's east zone from January last year to February this year. 

“Mridha, who became general manager (east) in January 2011, did not send the recruitment data on due date, as he tried to keep it secret,” said the source.

Mridha and Faruq might have taken bribes from applicants in advance, but failed to give them jobs within the February 11 deadline, it said. 

“They had to use back dates on documents to legalise appointments.” Many in the railway are aware of this malpractice, the source said.

There have been allegations of widespread irregularities in recruitment in the railway's east zone. Many job seekers alleged that they had to pay Tk 3 lakh to Tk 5 lakh for each post of Class III and IV employees.
Railway Director General Abu Taher said none could make recruitments on back dates. “This is illegal. Punitive action will be taken if anyone is found involved in such irregularities,” he told The Daily Star.

A departmental probe headed by the railway director general last month found no involvement of Suranjit in the Tk 70 lakh scandal. In its report on May 13, the probe body said the seized money belonged to Faruq.
The probe body prepared the report based on statements of Faruq, Mridha, Enamul and some BGB personnel.

Suranjit stepped down as railway minister on April 16 following the seizure of Tk 70 lakh from the microbus of his APS Omar Faruq. Many in the railway claimed the amount of money stashed in the vehicle amounted to several crores. 

On the night of April 9, Faruq's microbus driver Ali Azam drove the vehicle carrying Faruq and railway officials Mridha and Enamul Huq to the BGB headquarters in the capital. The driver loudly told the guards that there was illegal money in the microbus.

The BGB personnel searched the vehicle and found Tk 70 lakh, reportedly collected from job seekers, stashed in the vehicle. They detained the four but released them the next day after verifying their identities.
Faruq was sacked; and Mridha and railway divisional security commandant Enamul Huq were suspended following the incident.

RECRUITMENT IN WEST ZONE

A total of 443 people were recruited in the railway's west zone in a year from August 2010 to August last year. The general manager (west zone) sent the recruitment data to the railway headquarters every month in line with the rules. 

No recruitment was made in the west zone during the extended period of six months, said sources in the railway.

The general managers of the east and west zones enjoy absolute authority to recruit staff in the railway.

 

Police for mandatory national identity card (NIC) for cyber cafe users

The Police have proposed amendments to the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Act, 2006, keeping provision for mandatory use of national identity card (NIC) and registration of user's name and address for using cyber cafe to check growing incidence of cyber crimes.(The Independent)

Under the Police Reform Programme (PRP), Bangladesh police have urged the government to bring some amendments to the Act to bring all Internet providers -- cyber cafes and mobile phone companies - under the law, a cyber crime expert affiliated with PRP said.

After amendments to the Act the use of national identity card will be made mandatory for the cyber cafe users, he said adding that registration of the names and addresses of the users will also be mandatory for using cyber cafe,, as criminals usually use cyber cafes for committing such crimes, he said.

The Internet providers will have to close all the pornographic websites by using a centrally monitored server after the amendments, he said. Anyone failing to operate business abiding the law would face exemplary punishment, he added. Justifying the amendments he said the governments in Europe and the USA bring amendments to the information technology related Acts in every three months with the changed trend of such crimes.

In this regard Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Barrister Shafique Ahmed said, "A process is underway to amend the ICT Act-2006 to make the law effective in preventing the growing trend of cyber crimes."

Asked about the mobile phone crimes, the cyber crime expert said that police could easily identify the mobile used in crimes by its IMEI (International Mobile Equipment Identity) number and according to law import of mobile phones without IMEI number is prohibited.

Cyber crimes are increasing every day and such crimes have no boundary as one can hack website of a country. a criminal residing in London can withdraw money from a bank account in Bangladesh using modern technology.

"Cyber crime is not an issue that will go away, it will continue and, with new technologies emerging, it will remain a constant challenge for both the internal and international law enforcing agencies," high officials of the police said.

A cyber crime squad was set up in the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) in 2008 but even after four years of its formation it is failing to work smoothly due to lack of trained officials, necessary equipment and logistic support, they said.

International economic security will be vulnerable and online hacking will also increase, if we fail to introduce the mechanism of busting the digital crimes", they said

"There are some information more valuable than money and are to be protected. It is possible to nip a high-tech crime, if we get to know it before it is committed. It is impossible to fight against firearms with bows and arrows, they added.


UK asks Bangladesh for neutral probe into incidents of disappearance

The UK has called on Bangladesh to conduct an “impartial and transparent” investigation into the disappearance of Ilias Ali. Ali went missing in April while returning to his residence.

The UK has pressed Bangladesh for impartial and transparent investigations into the disappearance of M. Ilias Ali, a leader of main opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP), and others.

"We are concerned about the disappearance of Ilias Ali. Our high commissioner to Bangladesh and ambassadors of eight other European countries called on the Bangladesh authorities on May 9 and urged them to conduct thorough investigations into disappearances, including that of Ilias," British Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office Lord Howell told the House of Lords Monday.

The Minister of State was answering a question put forward by Labor Peer Lord Harris who asked what diplomatic representations were being made about the disappearance and alleged kidnapping of Ilias and other opposition politicians.

Ali, a former lawmaker and BNP organizing secretary of Sylhet Division, went missing along with his driver while returning to his Banani residence in the early hours of April 18.

Lord Howell also said, "We support Bangladesh in its efforts to stabilize its politics, to move towards the best kind of elections at the next appropriate time and to develop and lift its people out of poverty and the appalling environmental challenges that they also face."

He further said in meetings with the officials of the Prime Minister's Office and the foreign ministry, they had urged the Bangladesh government to do everything they could to trace Ilias and investigate the matter.

However, Britain feels the drive to end this "dark atmosphere" over Bangladeshi politics must come from within.

There are allegations, too, that the crime buster Rapid Action Battalion is involved.
Lord Howell also informed the House of Lords that the EU heads of mission during visit to Bangladesh in February stated its concerns very clearly.

Besides, UK's senior ministers, including the foreign secretary, have been in direct personal contact with senior officials, including the foreign minister, of Bangladesh.

"It is a concern for the UK because it is an important nation and destination of one of DFID's largest programs, with $1.57 billion due to go to support Bangladesh development over the next four years. It is a nation that the UK wants to see stable and prosperous and to build on its economic achievements, which are beginning to show dividends," said Lord Howell.

 

Saturday, May 19, 2012

For God’s sake, let Alfred Nobel rest in peace

ALFRED Nobel, a Swedish chemist, engineer and later industrialist, invented firstly dynamite and a decade later more powerful but smokeless ballistite, which enabled him to earn fortunes through his global interests in explosives and acquire large holdings in the Baku oil fields in Russia.

Fortunes thus earned fomented whisperingly in the ears of the unmarried man as Alfred Nobel was to make a will for Nobel Prize before his death in 1896.

By dint of the will, five Nobel Prizes were established in chemistry, physics, medicine, literature and peace. The Royal Academy of Science, Stockholm, was to award Nobel in physics and chemistry, the Royal Caroline Medico Institute for Medicines, Stockholm, medicine, the Swedish Academy for Literature, Stockholm, literature, and the Norwegian Nobel Committee, Oslo, peace. In 1969 the Nobel Prize for economic science was added in memory of Alfred Nobel by the Bank of Sweden.

In pursuance of the will, the Nobel Foundation is the legal owner and joint administrator along with the awarders of six prizes. The will further specifies that awards are to be made annually ‘to those who, during the preceding year, shall have conferred the greatest benefit to mankind.’

Alfred Nobel, basically a pacifist, witnessed devastating effects due to the rampant use of his inventions in warfare. He was literally moved and shocked and felt the need to do something about peace. Peace activist Bertha von Suttner, Nobel’s acquaintance, did also influence him immensely for world peace. Having regard to the development of global peace, Nobel added peace prize through inclusion in his will, ‘The said interest shall be divided into five equal parts, which shall be apportioned as follows: one part to the person who shall have done to the most or the best work for fraternity among nations, the abolition or reduction of standing armies, and for holding and promotion of peace congresses.’

Proposals for all Nobel prizes need to be submitted by February 1 every year and the final decision after due process by the committees of awardees is to be finalised by November 15. The peace prize has, however, been singled out to include not only individuals but also institutions.

Until 2011 the Nobel Peace Prize has been awarded to 101 individuals inclusive of 15 women, and 20 institutions. However, no award could be given for various reasons for 19 years. Apart from war effects and promotion of Peace therefore, the Nobel Peace Prize has been awarded within the purview of the ‘Will’ for reasons, other than warfare issues, the following list (mentioned only a few) will suffice for justification and judiciousness in order to award the Nobel Peace Prize for:-

Founding Red Cross.

Founding Inter Parliamentary Union.

Formulating general principles of science of international law.

Providing leadership in Peace movement.

Promotion of arbitration.

Dovetailing Peace societies with various nations.

Helping creation of League of Nations.

Helping to cope with famine.

Efforts to involve church, not only in work for ecumenical unity but also for world peace.

Social reform work and leading the Women’s International League for Peace and freedom.

Aiding refugees.

Companion for others through friends services and to desire to help them.

Founding International Relief Organisation.

Struggle against apartheid in South Africa.

Protection of human rights in the ICRC’s 100 years existence.

Campaign for civil rights without violence.

Contribution to the green revolution.

Founder of Missionaries of Charity.

Non-violent struggle for democracy and human rights.

Social justice and ethno-cultural reconciliation to respect the rights of the indigenous peoples
Contribution to sustainable development, democracy and peace.

Advancement of economic and social opportunities for the poor, especially women, through pioneering microcredit.

Disseminating greater knowledge about man-made climate change and how to tackle it.

Non-violent struggle for the safety of women and for their rights to full participation in peace-building work.

We have now arrived at the core issue of awarding of Nobel Peace Prize, 2006, to Prof Muhammad Yunus, Grameen Bank, Bangladesh, in consideration of advancement of economic and social opportunities for the poor, especially women through pioneering micro-credit.

Point to be noted here is that all other Nobel Prizes are awarded in retrospect often two or three decades after the awarded achievements, whereas the Nobel Peace Prize is awarded for more recent or immediate achievements.

Microcredit means small long term loan on easy terms for self-support of the poorest people, especially women, who have no means to provide security - a visionary concept of microcredit duly conceptualised by Prof Muhammad Yunus. More than 100 countries have now been trying to follow this concept. By 2006, the Grameen Bank had seven million borrowers with average loan amount of Tk 7000, the recovery rate being over 95 per cent. It is thus clear that of the above list shown as justification for consideration for Peace awards, microcredit stands out most. Nobel Peace Prize is a matter of high repute now-a-days globally, but a dismal picture has been hovering over the blue sky of Bangladesh. By now we have made the Nobel Peace award most un-peaceful, bitter and unwelcome, by uttering, bickering and jittering, that may be summed up as follows :-

Peace agreement with Chittagong Hill Tracts people should have the priority over all others to have been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, - so was claimed at the premises of the Supreme Court by a responsible officer of the govt. Perhaps, the core points of time frame, implementation and happiness enjoyed and so expressed by all concerned parties have been overlooked in such a claim. The Hill Tracts people have been raising hue and cry for package implementation. In factm there has been an aggravation in the matter as the govt has shown its inclination to changing the present nationality of ‘Bangladeshi’, conceptualized by Ziaur Rahman, to encompass all and sundry regardless of their mother tongue and local dialects, to ‘Bangalee’.

A minister’s simplified formulation of lobbying, attending parties, having cheese sandwich and white wine so on and so forth in various cosmopolitan capitals of the globe which would, in turn, enable some one to be entitled to Nobel Peace Prize has shown virtually fathomless depth of knowledge, in such a naive formulation. One may raise two, inter alia, valid questions:-

    (i) Why don’t you do the same for a peace award for Hill Tracts agreement?
    (ii) Are we not dwarfing the tall image of Nobel Laureates like, Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela, 

Desmond Tutu, Mother Teresa, Albert Lutuli, Rigoberta Menchú, Wangari Muta, Leymah Gbowee and a host of other stalwarts?

(c) A technocrat minister has invited Prof Muhammad Yunus and Sir Fazle Hasan Abed of BRAC to test their popularity by joining politics. The purposeful meaning of democracy is that you have to listen to the views of all and sundry whether they are in politics or not, for we know politicians shake the hands of the voters before vote and shake the bodies of the voters after the casting of votes. The minister’s invitation is tantamount to tuning Shivas’s songs while husking, the most irrelevant and unbecoming, though.

While the world is progressing we are falling apart with myopic vision that speaks of pulling down the ascender rather than ascend thyself.

It may also be pointed out here that Sir Fazle is the only Knighthood recipient since Bangladesh came into being, a great honour for Bangladesh as well. Sir Fazle, a UK-educated professional accountant who was earning handsomely in the late 1970’s, having been heavily shocked at the death of millions in 1970’s tidal bore in the coastal area of Bangladesh gave up his job and single-handedly formed Bangladesh Rural Advancement Centre, BRAC, as an NGO and over time turned it into the biggest NGO of the globe. Let us pull ourselves, and move heaven and hell to win another Nobel Peace Prize for Sir Fazle, a Magsaysay recipient, as such option seems to be bright and prospective.

Can we disprove presently the nature’s theorem as composed by Poet Swift’s line on poetry? :

‘So, naturalists observe, a flea
Hath smaller fleas that on him prey;
And these have smaller fleas to bite ’em,
And so proceed ad infinitum.
Thus every poet, in his kind
Is bit by him that comes behind.’
-Well, May I Say – ‘May God Help us’.